Tyranny of the Code: The (Hopeful) End of Coinbase

By Liberty Under Attack

Tyranny of the Code: The (Hopeful) End of Coinbase

By: Shane Radliff
June 16th, 2017
Download this article.

“Everyone in Bitcoin… are the worst kind of hucksters and characters you’ve ever seen. They have nothing better to do though, they couldn’t make it in traditional banking and now they’re here fucking it up for the rest of us.”

Cody Wilson

Image Credit: Bitcoin.com

When I use crypto-currencies, it’s for a number of reasons: their decentralized nature, privacy in financial transactions, subverting mainstream central banking, and, well, personal satisfaction—the overwhelming sense of freedom I feel in transacting with this medium of exchange is quite the high.

That said, Coinbase has managed to single-handedly undermine the main reasons why I choose to use crypto-currencies. I guess it was wise for me to never to do business with them.

Two years ago to the day (completely unintentional), I wrote about my first experiences in trying to acquire Bitcoin without revealing any personally identifiable information. My first attempt was through Coinbase. I was quickly dissuaded when they required me to upload a copy of my driver’s license before doing anything with them—even as a newbie, I still viewed that as contrary to the purpose of Bitcoin.

The results were similar with every exchange I tried, the exceptions being ones that were outside of the United States, and therefore, they weren’t legally allowed to do business across imaginary borders and a “big pool.”

I eventually was able to acquire the Bitcoin without a bank account, but it took a whole evening and I suffered ridiculously expensive transaction fees.

All of that said, I have been warning against Coinbase ever since. I’ve joked many times about how, “Next, they will require you to upload a blood sample for identity verification purposes.” Think biometrics.

It’s not that bad yet, but don’t worry, when the State asks Coinbase to jump, they ask, “How high?”

Let’s begin with probably the most important reason NOT to use Coinbase, if you are one of the folks who would rather not report taxes on your transactions/earnings in crypto-currencies.

On November 18th, 2016, Coinbase published a blog post revealing that the U.S. federal government is “seeking disclosure of all Coinbase U.S. customers’ records over a three year period” because “taxpayers may use virtual currency to evade taxes.”

Thankfully, Coinbase has at least had SOME sort of a spine in caring about their users’ privacy, and as of June 8th, they still have yet to turn over any user account information.

That’s no cause for celebration, though—I predict there will be a concession of some sort, whether that comes down to a more stringent tax reporting protocol (which co-founder Brian Armstrong is pushing for—see below), disclosing only certain accounts trading in high volume, or whatever.

In January of 2017, the communist state of New York granted a virtual currency and money transmitter license to Coinbase. This is unusual for a controlling monster like The Empire State, although not unsurprising since Coinbase is an IRS-compliant exchange, although hyper-compliant would be a better way to put it.

Fast forward to February 9th to a Forbes article, wherein Armstrong discusses how the IRS can rest assured knowing that users transacting in Bitcoin are paying their taxes “if we [Coinbase and the IRS] make it easy” for them to do so.

He sounds quite confident in that answer; I’ll refer to Vikram from The Office here: “Confidence…it’s the food of the wise man, but the liquor of the fool.”

The article further states that:

“Requiring a standardized process for reporting which could be utilized by the entire industry would help resolve some of the reporting concerns, says Coinbase and they’re prepared…to go first.”

I’d strongly prefer this sort of thing not become the industry standard, but I don’t think Coinbase is going to alter their path of possum-like submission to government entities.

If you’re a libertarian or an anarchist, you’re probably familiar with civil asset forfeiture and you should be against it, but those in Coinbase are apparently not (or, possibly, they are willing to compromise for the sake of “cooperation” with governments)—they seem to have no problem assisting the bludgies (i.e. police, aka the Bluecoats) in selling off their stolen Bitcoin seized in investigations, as revealed in a February CoinTelegraph article.


Why did the Vernon Hills Finance Department choose Coinbase, you might ask? Well, Nikki Larason, the finance director, “described Coinbase as a ‘police friendly’ trading platform and revealed that the police department’s asset forfeiture account will be linked to the village’s Coinbase account.”

It sounds like Coinbase and the bludgies will have a friendly, working relationship going into the future…Scary.

Speaking of horrifying, an article was published on Bitcoin.com in late February discussing one end user’s experience in attempting to create an account on Coinbase:

“Just tried to help a friend register an account and they’re demanding access to her webcam?!?! “[W]e will require you to take a photo of yourself with your webcam”….but no law or regulation requires this. I have accounts with 3 brokerage firms, 2 banks, and Gemini, and none have ever demanded access to my computer’s hardware. Coinbase, what are you trying to pull here? Accessing our computer’s hardware is not required by… laws/regulations. What’s your true endgame?”

One more case study was cited:

“I’ve had an account for three months and all of a sudden when I went to but [sic] more Bitcoin I was taken to a page to verify my identity again. I had already done that by uploading my license. This time they made me use my webcam and it took me eight tries because they kept saying it was too blurry.”

My use of the term “hyper-compliant” was not hyperbole—I wish it were—with their use of this facial recognition software, they are going over and beyond what is actually legally required and making their exchange that much more anti-privacy. Orwell, eat your heart out.

What’s next? Requiring new users to go through a retinal scan? Or, as I satirically pointed out earlier, a blood sample for ID verification?

Speaking of going over and beyond, Coinbase added Kathryn Haun, a former federal prosecutor, to their Board of Directors on June 14th—although she didn’t play a direct role with Ulbricht’s sentencing, she was involved in the takedown of two federal agents who stole money during the Silk Road investigation. She was the first ever Digital Currency coordinator for the Department of Justice, “with a focus on financial fraud, cybercrime, [and] digital currency.”

My immediate thought after discovering this was, “I wonder if Coinbase hired her based off of a ‘stern recommendation’ by the federal government?” With no possible way to verify that, I’ll leave that one up for you to ponder.

This story gets more interesting, though.

Not 24 hours after the aforementioned announcement, the Free Ross campaign revealed that Coinbase had frozen their account after an apparent transfer of ~$40,000 which was to be used for legal expenses.

With this highly suspect chronology of events, it really makes me wonder if the federal government’s control of Coinbase is beyond regulatory powers now—is this just the first example of a revolving door between the exchange and the feds? Realpolitik, much?

Lots of questions, with little to no answers.

So, what’s the takeaway?

Look, I get why people use Coinbase—the convenience of going in and out of Federal Reserve Notes (FRN’s) has to be nice, but when you look at their consistent strides away from privacy, their consistent collusion and hyper-compliance with regulatory powers, and the never-ending stories of how Coinbase randomly froze/suspended someone’s account without any foreknowledge (and subsequently making the withdrawal of remaining funds extremely difficult), it seems to be far more trouble than its worth.

But, what about other exchanges like Poloniex or Gemini? Honestly, I’ve never used an exchange that deals with FRN’s, so I’m really not sure if they would be any better—sure, maybe less scandalous, but there is the legally required identity verification step in setting up an account (since they deal with government fiat).

The choice between privacy and convenience is one that individuals will have to decide for themselves.

One might quip, “So, Shane, I’ve seen you post a lot about you speculating in crypto-currencies and such. How do you do all of that without using one of the aforementioned exchanges?”

The answer is two-fold: peer-to-peer transactions and the New Zealand based exchange, Cryptopia.

Cryptopia is an incredible exchange, and unlike Coinbase, Poloniex, or Gemini, since they don’t deal with government fiat, they don’t require ANY personally identifiable information. You can trade your crypto knowing your privacy is secure and your account offshore. The only catch is that you have to acquire some crypto-currency beforehand, in order to enter the exchange—and, when you want to cash out, you’ll likely have to go peer-to-peer or you can buy gift cards with Bitcoin through Gyft.com (or, as another option, you can buy a Walmart gift card and then subsequently purchase a Visa gift card).

Bitcoin was certainly a revolutionary development with a focus on decentralizing money. It has sparked a crypto-currency revolution that has improved the lives of millions, including the life of your humble author, and they will continue to do so.

The only real challenge that lies ahead is not a technological one—rather, it is exchanges like Coinbase and startups/developers selling out blockchain technology to make a quick buck.

I’ll leave you with this: I would love nothing more than to see the whole Coinbase infrastructure collapse—but, I’m no central planner, and the market will inevitably decide if Coinbase’s services are really necessary, or if it’s more worthwhile to go with a competitor.

If you’re as concerned as I am, if you see this chronology of events as being detrimental to crypto-currencies, I implore you to vote with your wallet and take your crypto-business elsewhere.

Endnote: Shoutout to Brian Sovryn for his coining of “tyranny of the code.” It worked so perfectly for this article, I had to use it.

Fields marked with an * are required

Sign up for LUA email updates to receive the FREE Direct Action Series, early access to every podcast, and more!

AlabamaAlaskaArizonaArkansasCaliforniaColoradoConnecticutDelawareDistrict of ColumbiaFloridaGeorgiaHawaiiIdahoIllinoisIndianaIowaKansasKentuckyLouisianaMaineMarylandMassachusettsMichiganMinnesotaMississippiMissouriMontanaNebraskaNevadaNew HampshireNew JerseyNew MexicoNew YorkNorth CarolinaNorth DakotaOhioOklahomaOregonPennsylvaniaRhode IslandSouth CarolinaSouth DakotaTennesseeTexasUtahVermontVirginiaWashingtonWest VirginiaWisconsinWyoming

The post Tyranny of the Code: The (Hopeful) End of Coinbase appeared first on Liberty Under Attack.

Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

  • mostrecentshows
  • Narrow Target Radio - 02/21/18

    Narrow Target Radio - 02/21/18Oh boy! After 3 weeks off with all of the events that have happened where are we to start? Oh yeah, Trump turning tail, Florida... freakin Florida! We talk about the lies and the misinformation being spread by media, Politicians and opportunists. We discuss comments made in the town hall meeting on gun violence and play some completely ludicrous commentary for Democratic Senator Bill Nelson and Marco Rubio. We outline the failures of the government that lead to the death of 17 kids and what we can do to correct it. We end the last 30 minutes by talking about [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 01/31/18

    Narrow Target Radio - 01/31/18This week Mark starts off with the state of affairs with the State of the Union and why we all can't just form our own opinions. After the first break he talks about custom paint, his new MSR build and Max Ordinate solutions' long range training program. After a glitch in the matrix, Mark talks about the new concealed carry holster he received from GFI before revisiting the classic AR line from Brownells. Narrow Target Radio is dedicated to personal enrichment through personal defense and personal liberty. Topics range from firearms, training, products and personal preparedness. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6e1crs PRESS PLAY BUTTON BELOW FOR AUDIO VERSION Click [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 01/24/18

    Narrow Target Radio - 01/24/18After a week off we start the show recapping what the hell our elected officials have been doing and the buffoonery in D.C. After the first break Mark gets into the happenings at shot show in Las Vegas. First he talks about the winners. The manufacturers doing it right and making products we want. Companies like Sig Sauer, Ruger, Brownells, Palmetto State Armory and New Frontier Armory. After we discuss some of the good products Mark lays out the massive failure of Franklin Armory and their (never should have been) Reformation. Narrow Target Radio is dedicated to personal enrichment through personal [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 01/10/18

    Narrow Target Radio - 01/10/18Tonight, we start the show disgusted at the state of our legal systems response to the Hillary Clinton situation. Mark and Nolan talk about his experience in his first formal firearms training class after Mark talks about a new release and a cancellation from Sig Sauer. After the first break we talk about Mark mentoring a friend for his first AR build and we spend some time dispelling bad information about manufacturing methods of the AR rifles after bad information was passed across the gun store counter. Squibs came up in reference to a customer gun Mark worked on and we [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 01/03/18

    Narrow Target Radio - 01/03/18Tonight was a full round-the-world tour. We start in California, then go to Indiana and the new Glock G19X with the dangers of using a safe action and a low quality holster. FIRE SPRINKLERS! Finally, Mark talks about mindset, situational awareness and the importance of constant self evaluation to fight tactical complacency. Narrow Target Radio is dedicated to personal enrichment through personal defense and personal liberty. Topics range from firearms, training, products and personal preparedness. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6cm5nr PRESS PLAY BUTTON BELOW FOR AUDIO VERSION Click for More about Narrow Target Radio LIVE: Wednesdays 10:00pm-12:00am [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 12/27/17

    Narrow Target Radio - 12/27/17Mark starts the show celebrating this weeks revelations in the news about our reduced federal extortion for tax money. Mark and Producer Nolan talk about his upcoming firearms training and how it is influencing his selection of his first personal defense pistol. Mark then spends some time explaining the difference between flash hiders and muzzle breaks, and the importance of choosing the correct one for your build. Lastly we talk about the iron sights on the AR15 and the what and why of how they are designed as well as how to keep the integrity of the sight picture when [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 12/20/17

    Narrow Target Radio - 12/20/17This week Mark rejoices in the passing of a long awaited tax break, celebrates the overwhelming sadness of Bernie Sanders and then gets down to business. In the second segment Mark demonstrates the Mantis telemetry training aid. He demonstrates the use and benefits of the app and how it can benefit your dry fire and live fire training. He discussed the importance of building constructive training habits while dry fire training and how we represent the community as CHL/CCW holder and how to talk to non firearms owners. Narrow Target Radio is dedicated to personal enrichment through personal defense and personal [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 12/13/17

    Narrow Target Radio - 12/13/17Tonight Mark talks about why he isn't going to be political on the show anymore and in the process, he gets political. Later he discusses carry options for when you are unable to carry normally. He tests drives the Versa Carry 2 with disastrous results. The topic migrates to the MSR concept, James Yeager, spotting shabby instructors and choosing a cartridge before ending the show. Narrow Target Radio is dedicated to personal enrichment through personal defense and personal liberty. Topics range from firearms, training, products and personal preparedness. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6bmuxf PRESS PLAY BUTTON BELOW FOR AUDIO VERSION Click for More about Narrow Target Radio LIVE: Wednesdays 10:00pm-12:00am [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 12/06/17

    Narrow Target Radio - 12/06/17To start the show, Mark recaps what he has been doing on his hiatus from broadcasting. Later as the technical issues with the video feed subside, he demonstrates a great tool for at home firearms training to stay sharp through the winter, discusses mindset and its importance in regards to EDC and urban life and finally he finishes up with a new perspective on back up sights and shows a new product he has come to use as his standard back up sight. Narrow Target Radio is dedicated to personal enrichment through personal defense and personal liberty. Topics range from firearms, training, [more]

    Can A Country Survive With Open Borders? - Disassociation Nation - 11/28/16

    Can A Country Survive With Open Borders? - Disassociation Nation - 11/28/16Niz and Paul welcome Shane Radliff to talk about his Direct Action series and a discussion burning up the Liberty community, Muh Borders! It's Spy vs. Spy vs You as the UK sets up to pass the largest domestic spy legistaltion in Western History. What happened to Kanye West? We announce our Tyrant of the week, and find out what's in your Aloe Vera. Disassociation Nation reveals the sordid underbelly of the dystopian reality of the American Dream.  We explore that reality while examining the principles of liberty that could liberate us all from the coercive enterprise that is the United States [more]

  • addwaystolisten
    FPRN Archives
    Whether you want to listen to the newest show, or take a trip to the past & check out some of our oldest broadcasts, you can find it all in the archives. Feel free to browse, download, or just stream, you can do it all right from the show's profile page:

    1. Head to the FPRN Radio Archives.
    2. Select the show of your choice (for show descriptions/bios, see our All Shows Page).
    3. Once on the profile page of the show you selected, you can listen to and/or download the latest broadcast, as well as any previous broadcast.
    Tune In Radio
    Begin listening to the FPRN Radio live stream on your smartphone or mobile device NOW from virtually anywhere with Tune In Radio for Apple iOS and Android:

    1. Go to the App Store on your smartphone or mobile device.
    2. Do a search for Tune In Radio.
    3. Download the App to your smartphone or mobile device.
    4. Once the download is complete, open the App and type FPRN Radio in the search bar.
    5. Click Enter and begin listening.
    6. To save FPRN Radio in the presets, tap on the heart while listening to the stream.
    Listen to your favorite shows on-demand on your PC, smartphone or mobile device when you subscribe to the FPRN Radio iTunes Podcast. Here's how:
    1. To subscribe with your computer, open iTunes, go to the iTunes Store & search for FPRN Radio and subscribe.
    2. To subscribe with your smartphone or mobile device, you will first need a podcasting app.
    3. We recommend Apple's Podcast App(free with the latest iOS), Downcast($1.99 for iOS) or OneCast(free for Android).
    4. Once downloaded, open the app & Browse or Search for FPRN Radio and Subscribe to the podcast.
  • vtuner
  • streamfinder
  • schedulebanner