Building The Second Realm #9: Autonomy and Peace, Second Realm Foundations (LUA Podcast #78)

By Liberty Under Attack

In this episode of Liberty Under Attack Radio, I cover some housekeeping notes and then you hear a spoken discourse of a really terrific blog post by Smuggler or XYZ, which introduced their book, Second Realm: Book on Strategy. It clearly answers the question, “Why is building the Second Realm necessary?”

You can find the entire blog post following the show notes.

Please enjoy this conversation, share the podcast around, and consider financially supporting the podcast–we need YOUR help to keep this going. You can become a patron on Patreon for exclusive content by clicking the image below. You can also donate crypto-currencies by clicking here.

Show Notes:
Second Realm: Book on Strategy
DEBATE: Adam Kokesh v. Graham Smith on the Efficacy and Ethics of Political Crusading

Autonomy and Peace, Second Realm Foundations

With the first post on this blog I would like to set the stage for what we are trying to accomplish.

About everyone agrees that there is something “wrong” with how the world operates today – and we chime into that choir. But our analysis and solutions are radically different. What is it that goes wrong? What should be done instead? And, most of all, who should do it? What is our reasoning?

In my opinion there is a single basic error at work that leads to the destruction of everything that is worth living for, at least for some of us. It is the erosion of the foundations of human interaction, human society, the whole human space itself. Big words, but they are not unfounded. Instead of whining about the precise details of what is going down the hill and what path it takes in the decline, lets have a little refreshing air from what the foundations should be (in my opinion).

What should be the foundation of human society, and what do we choose as the foundation of our work on the Second Realm?

It starts out with a simple statement: Humans are not just animals like all others. No – we have that little unnerving feature of being able to reason, abstract, think, choosing responsibility. We are moral actors. That is what sets us apart and constitutes the cornerstone of where the animal kingdom ends and the human world begins. Contrary to what some ideologies try to teach us, or at least assume, is the simple statement that all (with very few, extreme examples that I actually cannot think of right now) humans are moral actors, and no matter what some say: We remain in that position and cannot get rid of it, we cannot delegate it, we cannot deny it. We are stuck in what we are and what makes us so special (even though some people spend countless words and trying to escape this minute fact).

For most readers of this blog, the above probably is a trivial truism, nothing to talk about again. However, it is not that simple. From that cornerstone comes the key to how people should live together – since they cannot realistically escape it, nor should they – and thus the basics for what governs the Second Realm. In short, it is the argument for autonomy.

Autonomy refers to the legitimacy and ability of single individuals making decisions for themselves, and giving themselves a moral law by which to operate. This does not mean that they will always be smart and successful in their decision-making, nor that their choices will be intellectually defendable or theologically sound (for those that care) – by no means. It only erects a borderline, a sphere that no other human being can justifiably ignore and trespass. The core of asserting autonomy is to see that it is the individual making choices for himself – not others choosing for him, nor he choosing for others. It is the line in the sand that says: “This is where I am the only one to decide”. Why? Because we are moral actors. That is one of the key rediscoveries the Enlightenment was said to have made.

At the same time, autonomy is a problem – at least for us. Since we assert that every human is a human actor, and thus everyone has autonomy, a statement of dire consequences was made. It is that of Equality of autonomy. There is no human underclass that lacks the legitimacy of making their own decisions. Nor is there a nature-given scheme in which the authority of making decisions for oneself is subdivided, increased or decreased between groups of humans and others. In this specific sense we are actually the same – we are equals. Out of this arises the problem of conflicting decisions of multiple autonomous humans. Each of them has the right to decide for himself, but since our decisions are often contrary to the interest and decisions of others, we get to what might be called the struggle of human society: Whose decision is to be implemented? Who has the right to decide now? The strongest? The oldest? The wisest? Equality of Autonomy forbids us from preferring the one over the other. It even forbids us to ask the masses for a vote. It puts us into the dire situation of either fighting and dropping our asserted autonomy – or to find a solution.

Surely many solutions have been proposed. Actually most of recorded history concerns itself with these kinds of conflicts. All those big political theories are about exactly this single question: Who decides in case of conflict? There are some that claim that no solution is necessary, that might makes right and that we should simply solve this issue by means of social Darwinism.

In all honesty I have never met someone who still holds to that position when his opponent is the one to put it into practice first and strongest. It is an animal way of solving conflict – at least at first sight. In the end, even animals are “more human” in that regard than many men are. It is the “don’t think but kill” mentality, the easiest shortcut for people to take if they are either morally damaged, too lazy to search for other solutions or simply too full of themselves. “Yay,” one might say “You are arguing in circles and without enough reason to argue at all.” Maybe, but do not most healthy people prefer peace over war? Not risking to be killed in a duel about who eats the steak? Who proposes “might makes right” has given up the foundation of reason itself – there is no means of any reasoning anymore. Is not reason itself not about killing those of different opinion but rather finding out what is “true” or at least “probable”? If it is, might there be not a similar measure to what makes human conflict reasonable? I suggest so, as much as reasoning is about finding “Truth”, conflict-resolution is about “Peace“.

Do not get me wrong: I am not speaking about “Peace by all means”. Rather I only say that it is what we long for. As much as “Truth” is not about people necessarily ending their line of argument “Peace” is not about people simply starting to love each other under all circumstances. Rather, it is “keep the Peace as long as it is up to you”.

Therefore, we are still lacking a solution for conflict. How can we both preserve Autonomy and Peace? The answer to it is rather trivial if you do not have a hidden agenda. One has to create spheres of legitimate, justifiable, undeniable and exclusive decision making for each individual. This solution is so simple that it has been found thousands of years ago by people that did not have the enormous body of philosophical reasoning available that we have. To the contrary, much of our political philosophy and the excrements of today’s intellectual class is just about denying this solution. It is the core of most of our political battles and inter-personal animosities. Nevertheless, it is just a small word, a simple concept, something that does not hurt anyone by itself. Not magical, complicated or requiring years of public education. Every child knows it before it has been taught all about it: Property.

One can spend countless hours on questions of what can be property, how one comes about to own something as property, and a myriad of other questions. Most of those however are just smoke and fog. Because it is actually simple. At least if one is aware that it is just the solution to the conflict-problem of equal autonomy of moral actors called “humans”. As long as we are willing to remember its purpose – the ability to act on or with things that exclude conflicting decisions – it remains simple. Surely, details can be discussed and different schools of thought on property acquisition and abandonment came into existence. Those specifics are often moot points to discuss in reality. It matters little to me how those questions are answered by someone five thousand miles away from me (because it is rarely the case I am in conflict with someone not present). As long as property acquisition leads to exclusivity of control over it and gives the owner space for autonomous decision making the problem can be considered solved in most cases. It does however require that autonomy of each individual is actually respected. And this is where the rubber hits the road and the frogs the fan:

When one looks at the battle of ideologies today and the ruffling of feathers of the political class, one can see that no matter what they say, in the end it comes down to one thing: “No, we do not respect the autonomy of individuals nor do we think that peace is a goal to strive for.” That is all what politics and social struggle is about. It is the focus of political philosophy from almost all ends. Finding excuses to deny autonomy – and therefore moral-actor-being – to the one or the other group of people. Excuses for conflict, war, theft. That’s contemporary politics in two five sentences, nothing else worth knowing about it.

Thus we have come to the reason why the Second Realm is so important to me, and also what its foundations are. It is about respecting the Autonomy of each individual and keeping the Peace. That given, we can finally focus on making progress, winning the survival-struggle, being fully human. I am simply tired of being treated as a dumb animal – I AM ALIVE AND I AM HUMAN. I guess I made that clear now.

Of course it does not really stop there. As much as the Second Realm is something I am longing for, it is also something many others want. Something many others need from the depths of their hearts. But I cannot speak for them. They are autonomous beings as well, and have not made me their speaker or master. It is just me, having the same hurting longing for liberty. It’s now up to us to cooperate in making progress along that road.

There are some final words missing for this article so far, and I intend to at least touch one open question without doing it full service. Above I chose to put Autonomy at the root of my reasoning. Not everyone will agree. There are three other roots for questions of human society. One is that there is no root at all, that nothing has sense, purpose or measure. I ignore that basis since I simply prefer people of positive outlook at a minimum common ground to talk with. If there is nothing to judge by, there is no reason to think at all.

Another possible root is the statement of fulfilling a higher purpose and law, some transcendent and – for the outsider – elusive scheme of things. That might be true or not. However, it does not have to conflict with what I said above. Many of these transcendent laws that we find in major religions around the world simply include all of the above but add some more to it. Let’s agree on the basics and see where it leads us. And those of the higher purposes that are non-religious in nature … let’s just say that I do not care that much. Call me arrogant, but I have better things to do.

The last of those different roots for society is a much different kind of beast. It is the assumption that “Life” and “Survival” are the roots of social decision making. For some people this might be what they feel and need – yes, it can actually be argued for. However, it cannot be the end of the question. No matter if a “life”-based social ethic actually leads to preserving life is out of scope for this article. One thing however is not: What is it that makes Life so valuable, so important? What makes the survival of an ant different from the survival of a man? Is it maybe that life for humans is living as humans should, first being moral actors and enjoying autonomy in peace? Or is it just spreading our genes (if so, see the question of no root at all. I owe nothing to evolution or nature, thank you).

Life-based arguing however comes from the deep down doubts of if the conclusion of autonomy, property, is going too far. Surely there are people that have a hard time on their own, no question. But should we not be self-enabled to help others out of our own free choices – our autonomy, in peace, using our property? Many doubt that we would, and to those I pose the question: “Would you? Or is it maybe that you don’t want to bear the weight of liberty equally – granting liberty to others while enjoying it yourself.”

Be seeing you.

The post Building The Second Realm #9: Autonomy and Peace, Second Realm Foundations (LUA Podcast #78) appeared first on Liberty Under Attack.

Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

  • mostrecentshows
  • Narrow Target Radio - 06/13/18

    Narrow Target Radio - 06/13/18We start this show with the topic of the day North Korea, but not the way you would think. Mark lays out his assessment of Kim Jong Un and how he is actually planning on westernizing North Korea and has been planning it all along. Anthony Bourdain, California 3 way split, California gun law traps, and local crime and government failures to manage it is also discussed and we end the show with some training talk, and pleasant conversation with Nolan.     Narrow Target Radio is dedicated to personal enrichment through personal defense and personal liberty. Topics range from firearms, training, products [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 06/06/18

    Narrow Target Radio - 06/06/18After a very long break for most of the month of May we start the show with a very long winded MY BAD and some talk about Indy car. Mark talks a bit about the sig P365 and the developments surrounding reported failures and Sig Sauer's reaction. Trump mania continues so we do touch on The Commander of Cheese before discussing recent school shootings, the swamp, the Bergdahl decision and just because Mark can't help himself he does explain his stance on how safe action isn't fail safe.     Narrow Target Radio is dedicated to personal enrichment through personal defense and personal [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 05/09/18

    Narrow Target Radio - 05/09/18Tonight, Mark starts the show talking about his experience stopping a daylight rape right behind his house last Sunday. He then talks about his local government purposely adjusting crime rates through false reporting and giving criminals a pass. Later he talks about making personal adjustments to your equipment, the NRAAM 2018 cultural shake up and old guard and Trumps crazy approach to successfully making our foreign affairs great again.     Narrow Target Radio is dedicated to personal enrichment through personal defense and personal liberty. Topics range from firearms, training, products and personal preparedness. PRESS PLAY BUTTON BELOW FOR AUDIO VERSION Click for More about Narrow [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 04/25/18

    Narrow Target Radio - 04/25/18Mark starts the show doing his new gun happy dance as he tells us about the Sig 229 trade saga. After his gleeful celebrating of the new pistol we talk about various topics to include Britain, Congress, the Dallas and Waffle house shootings. He talks about Tim at the Military Arms Channel and how he has launched a campaign to get the NRA back into the fight and to stop the capitulation.     Narrow Target Radio is dedicated to personal enrichment through personal defense and personal liberty. Topics range from firearms, training, products and personal preparedness. PRESS PLAY BUTTON BELOW FOR AUDIO VERSION Click for [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 04/18/18

    Narrow Target Radio - 04/18/18Mark spends the opening of the show talking about talking about training plans, exploding airplanes and his new rifle he is waiting for. After the break he talks about some of the crazy questions his new coworker asks, open carry in a big city, the death of slide fire, his plans for participation in a local buy back program in order to save guns from the melting furnace. Then we get into Syria, Korea and why the left is so distracted by their hate they pay not attention to what is actually going on.   Narrow Target Radio is dedicated to personal [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 04/11/18

    Narrow Target Radio - 04/11/18After a few weeks break Mark catches up the listeners with his misadventures in gun shows and quitting tobacco. We discuss the current gun debate and the way that pro 2A supporters voices are being silenced while the social media moguls lie to the nation about it. We end the show on Syria and why it should not be a thing.       Narrow Target Radio is dedicated to personal enrichment through personal defense and personal liberty. Topics range from firearms, training, products and personal preparedness. PRESS PLAY BUTTON BELOW FOR AUDIO VERSION Click for More about Narrow Target Radio LIVE: Wednesdays 10:00pm-12:00am [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 03/21/18

    Narrow Target Radio - 03/21/18This week Mark talks about his experience with the Rockwell tactical Mindset seminar at the Muncie Threat Assessment Center. Then we get both feet into the current relationship the left has with the rest of us and the gun debate as well as Youtube's treatment and dismissal of gun channels from their site. Before we come to an unscheduled early finish, Mark talks about the state of affairs in South Africa and the US, USSR, UK snafu. Narrow Target Radio is dedicated to personal enrichment through personal defense and personal liberty. Topics range from firearms, training, products and personal preparedness. PRESS PLAY [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 03/07/18

    Narrow Target Radio - 03/07/18This week we talk about NY, Chicago, Florida and California and the lunacy of the liberal advance against our gun rights. Obama makes a come back and we play some very excellent clips to support our argument. Mark talks about how Indiana is getting almost civilized with Sunday alcohol sales and how his dumbass Governor thinks hemp is pot. We finish up the evening talking about Marks upcoming training with RTG and weapons mounted lights. Narrow Target Radio is dedicated to personal enrichment through personal defense and personal liberty. Topics range from firearms, training, products and personal preparedness. PRESS PLAY BUTTON BELOW [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 02/28/18

    Narrow Target Radio - 02/28/18On this weeks show, Mark recaps all the lies and failures we have learned about the Parkland shooting after the CNN town hall aired. We go on to talk about how POTUS has seemingly switched from pro 2A to no 2A and his collusion with Dianne Fascist-stein, the push to confiscate without due process, the various effects on companies who have both supported and ended relationships with the NRA. In the second half of the show we talk about the Las Vegas shooting and the recent legal developments regarding the release of autopsy records of the victims and how we still [more]

    Narrow Target Radio - 02/21/18

    Narrow Target Radio - 02/21/18Oh boy! After 3 weeks off with all of the events that have happened where are we to start? Oh yeah, Trump turning tail, Florida... freakin Florida! We talk about the lies and the misinformation being spread by media, Politicians and opportunists. We discuss comments made in the town hall meeting on gun violence and play some completely ludicrous commentary for Democratic Senator Bill Nelson and Marco Rubio. We outline the failures of the government that lead to the death of 17 kids and what we can do to correct it. We end the last 30 minutes by talking about [more]

  • addwaystolisten
    FPRN Archives
    Whether you want to listen to the newest show, or take a trip to the past & check out some of our oldest broadcasts, you can find it all in the archives. Feel free to browse, download, or just stream, you can do it all right from the show's profile page:

    1. Head to the FPRN Radio Archives.
    2. Select the show of your choice (for show descriptions/bios, see our All Shows Page).
    3. Once on the profile page of the show you selected, you can listen to and/or download the latest broadcast, as well as any previous broadcast.
    Tune In Radio
    Begin listening to the FPRN Radio live stream on your smartphone or mobile device NOW from virtually anywhere with Tune In Radio for Apple iOS and Android:

    1. Go to the App Store on your smartphone or mobile device.
    2. Do a search for Tune In Radio.
    3. Download the App to your smartphone or mobile device.
    4. Once the download is complete, open the App and type FPRN Radio in the search bar.
    5. Click Enter and begin listening.
    6. To save FPRN Radio in the presets, tap on the heart while listening to the stream.
    Listen to your favorite shows on-demand on your PC, smartphone or mobile device when you subscribe to the FPRN Radio iTunes Podcast. Here's how:
    1. To subscribe with your computer, open iTunes, go to the iTunes Store & search for FPRN Radio and subscribe.
    2. To subscribe with your smartphone or mobile device, you will first need a podcasting app.
    3. We recommend Apple's Podcast App(free with the latest iOS), Downcast($1.99 for iOS) or OneCast(free for Android).
    4. Once downloaded, open the app & Browse or Search for FPRN Radio and Subscribe to the podcast.
  • vtuner
  • streamfinder
  • schedulebanner